Hyphen or not?
Our lesson today, class, is about when and when not to hyphenate phrases.
Hyphenate adjective phrases. You can have set-up instructions, a step-by-step plan, a last-minute trip, living-room furniture, and out-of-the-box thinking. All these phrases are adjectives. They describe nouns (technically the word should be the more generic term “substantives,” not “nouns.” “Thinking” isn’t a noun, it’s a gerund.)
Do not hyphenate phrasal verbs or prepositional phrases. You sign up for a trip, set up a process, hook up a connection, sign in to your account. You can put down the box, and you can pull over to the side of the road (verbs), you plan step by step, go on a trip at the last minute, keep it under your hat, and you think out of the box (prepositional phrases).
Some phrases are used as nouns. “That was a nasty put-down.”
One type of exception to these hyphenations: Some phrases have become so common they have turned into compound words. You have a pickup truck, a login ID, and a nice setup.
Can you think up some better examples? Put your own thought-of phrases in the comments.
Interestingly, I’ve noticed that people over “quote” and, over-comma, but they are more likely to under hyphenate! Heck, should over-quote and over-comma be hyphenated? They’re not adjective phrases. Wait, maybe they’re phrases used as nouns, and therefore should be hyphenated. My native-English-speaker instinct makes me want to hyphenate them since they really aren’t part of the sentence structure and are being used as nouns.
This was very interesting. I enjoyed your analogy and your comments.
We are trying to establish a simple plan for all of my team to use other than the various style books
However, I like your style.
It is real logic!
Dianne Bell
Director of Communications
MDES
Would you hyphenate “vanilla fudge swirl ice cream” or “vanilla fudge ice cream” — or would this be over-hyphenating?
I’ve never seen ice cream flavors hyphenated, but you could if you consider the adjectives to make a compound. Perhaps they’re not hyphenated because technically those modifiers are nouns (used attributively).
There are a lot of borderline situations with hyphenation also. For example, if you’re talking about a high school reunion, it’s grammatically courteous to hyphenate it as “high-school reunion.” However, a lot of grammarians appear to accept it as “high school reunion.”
outside-the-box thinking
out-of-the-box means how things are at default.
out-of-the-box experience, or features
@Andrea – Vanilla-fudge-swirl ice cream. Because that’s different to Vanilla, fudge-swirl ice cream. Honestly the latter is probably better. Or is it?
This blog post is from 2009 – I don’t think I’ve read a blog post or even commenting on one in the last 5 years… woah.
Good tips, thanks! Interested in the ice cream compound name questions posed, yep yep.